Teaching Elementary School Social Studies
Taught by Christy Keeler, Ph.D.


Homepage
Syllabus
Outline
Readings
Materials
Communications/Grades

Note:  If you are unclear about any aspect of this assignment, email Christy Keeler immediately.

Assignment: Reflective Classroom Observations
Due Date: March 22, 2007
Link to Word File: http://coe.nevada.edu/ckeeler/SSM/Assignments/ReflectiveObservations.doc

Description:

You will need to engage in two non-sequential reflective observations of elementary teachers as they deliver social studies curricula. You will present your reflections as a "project." You may choose to write journal entries, record audio files, prepare forms, create videos, use Dinah Zike paper folding, or use any other creative media. Complete each reflection immediately following the observation so it is fresh in your mind. See http://coe.nevada.edu/ckeeler/SSM/StudentWork/Assessment_Product_Possibilities.html for additional suggestions, but feel free to use your own idea.

Your project must address the following:
  • General information about the lesson
    • The grade level of the students;
    • Intended student learning outcomes;
    • The teacher's selected method of instruction;
    • The relationship of the curricular objectives to those noted in the NCSS Standards and the CCSD CEF; and,
    • A description of the written lesson plan.
  • Issues of classroom management
    • Teacher behaviors contributing to an enhanced learning environment;
    • Classroom organizational features that enhance content delivery of the specific behavioral objectives for the lesson; and,
    • The role of content and instructional methodology in managing classroom behavior.
  • Personal reaction to the lesson
    • What you liked and disliked about the lesson;
    • Elements of the lesson you would use if teaching it yourself; and,
    • Elements of the lesson you would not use if teaching the lesson yourself and a justification for your alternative methods.

You may situate your observations in a larger unit, but focus on a single lesson for this assignment. Each observation should be from a separate unit if possible.

To maintain confidentiality, do not use the name of the school, teacher, and students' names. Be sure to note in the text if you use a pseudonyms.


Reflective Classroom Observations Grading Rubric


Name: ___________________________________   Course: __458  __658  Section:  __001  __002  __004  Total: ___/30 per observation

For EACH Observation, use the following rubric.


5
4
3
2
1
0
Score
Professionalism of Product
Professional delivery and syntax



No spelling and grammatical errors or few recognizable  errors.
Several syntactical errors.
Replete with errors.

Writing is clear and detailed

Thorough presentation of content delivered in a clear, concise, and meaningful manner. Detail focuses on social studies while portraying a consistent professional tone.
Writing is clear and detailed.
Writing lacks clarity or detail.
Writing lacks clarity and detail.
Writing is incomprehensible.

Recognition of school/ teacher/students confidentiality



School, teacher, and students are either not identified by name, or are identified using an explicitly stated pseudonym.

School, teacher, or students' names are stated.

Respect for the teacher/students as subjects of observation



Writing portrays an appreciation of the position of the teacher and a respect for students. Subjects are described in human terms and all judgment is based on academic or philosophical evidence.
Writing portrays a professional tone, but some inattention to  diplomacy.
Writing does not portray an appreciation of the position of the teacher and a respect for students.

Content
Focus on elementary-level social studies education







Identifies general information about lesson


Clearly lists grade level, intended student learning outcomes, and method(s) of instruction. Explicitly details lesson procedures and activities.
Lists two of the following: grade level, intended student learning outcomes, and method(s) of instruction, and explicitly detail lesson procedures and activities. Lists two of the following: grade level, intended student learning outcomes, and method(s) of instruction, but fails to explicitly detail lesson procedures and activities. Fails to explicitly detail lesson procedures, activities, and general information.
Relates lesson to standards and local curriculum guide

Identifies all related NCSS Standards and local social studies curricular objectives.
Identifies most related NCSS Standards and most local social studies curricular objectives. Identifies all related NCSS Standards or all related local social studies curricular objectives. Identifies some related NCSS Standards or some related local social studies curricular objectives. Does not identify related NCSS Standards or local social studies curricular objectives.
Relates written to delivered lesson

Describes and includes a copy of the teacher-created lesson plan and provides a detailed comparison between written lesson plan and delivered lesson.
Describes or includes a copy of the teacher-created lesson plan and provides a comparison between written lesson plan and delivered lesson. Describes or includes a copy of the teacher-created lesson plan and provides a  comparison between written lesson plan and delivered lesson. Describes or includes a copy of the teacher-created lesson plan or provides a weak comparison between written lesson plan and delivered lesson. Does not address written lesson plan.

Addresses issues of classroom management

Clearly details:
  • Teacher behaviors contributing to or detracting from an enhanced learning environment
  • Classroom organizational features that enhance or detract from content delivery of the specific behavioral objectives for the lesson
  • The role of content and instructional methodology in managing classroom behavior.
Suggests ways that these behaviors/techniques contributed to student learning or detracted from it. Suitable alternatives are suggested for managerial or instructional improvements in the case that student behaviors were unacceptable.
Clearly details:
  • Teacher behaviors contributing to or detracting from an enhanced learning environment
  • Classroom organizational features that enhance or detract from content delivery of the specific behavioral objectives for the lesson
  • The role of content and instructional methodology in managing classroom behavior.
Identifies two of the following:
  • Teacher behaviors contributing to or detracting from an enhanced learning environment
  • Classroom organizational features that enhance or detract from content delivery of the specific behavioral objectives for the lesson
  • The role of content and instructional methodology in managing classroom behavior.
Identifies one of the following:
  • Teacher behaviors contributing to or detracting from an enhanced learning environment
  • Classroom organizational features that enhance or detract from content delivery of the specific behavioral objectives for the lesson
  • The role of content and instructional methodology in managing classroom behavior.
Fails to address issues of classroom management and student behaviors.

Includes personal reflection
Reflection  is thorough and honest and explicitly relates to personal philosophy of social studies education. Reflection thoroughly addresses how lesson aligns with or fails to align to specific educational theories, preferred instructional methodologies, or philosophical beliefs of authors in the field of education.
Reflection  is thorough and honest and explicitly relates to personal philosophy of social studies education. Reflection addresses how lesson aligns with or fails to align to specific educational theories, preferred instructional methodologies, or philosophical beliefs of authors in the field of education. Reflection  is thorough and honest and explicitly relates to personal philosophy of social studies education. Reflection  is thorough and honest, but the relationship to individual social studies education is lacking. Reflection is superficial.
Does not include a personal reflection of the lesson quality.

Total
___/30



©2007 Christy Keeler